Medical Philosophy in Islam

administrator

Islamic Medicine
Staff member
FOREWORD

In the name of Allah, the Most Beneficent, the Most Merciful

Islam today stands on the threshold of a new era. After almost 400 years of stagnation, Islamic civilization is beginning to reassert itself in the affairs of modern society. Muslims throughout the world are critically reassessing, and re-evaluating the philosophies and ideologies of today and finding them wanting. Increasingly, they are turning to Islam and through its book of guidance the Quran and the example of the Prophet (SAW), seeking solutions for the problems of today.

This revival of Islam is influencing all branches of knowledge including the humanities, and the natural sciences. Medical science too is caught up in this revival. The concept of Islamic medicine is now openly discussed and debated and Muslim physicians are now proudly professing their loyalty to Islamic medicine. They are justifiably proud of the outstanding contributions made by the early Muslim scientists in such fields as medicine, astronomy, mathematics and optics, etc., contributions, which for centuries have been suppressed and indeed plagiarised by western scientists. The West has consistently and systematically played down the contribution of Muslim scientists to civilization. Most historians conveniently ignore the intervening period from Greek civilization to the Renaissance - a period during which Islamic civilization reached its zenith.

Hopefully, this is no longer to be. As Muslims we have the responsibility to set the records straight. In this monograph, Prof. Haq Nadvi has set out to do so, and has in my opinion succeeded admirably. He discusses the philosophy of medical treatment in Islam, based on the Quran and the Sunna of our Prophet (SAW) and outlines the contribution made by our early Muslim physicians and scientists to medicine, both in original discoveries and in propagating these through their medical writings. He shows how most of these were translated into Latin and used in Europe for centuries as standard reference texts on medicine. He critically analyses the assessment of Orientalist to Arabic medical literature and shows clearly how this was influenced by their bias against Islam. Indeed he demonstrates very well how Greek medicine which has and still is considered to be the foundation of modern medicine has its origins in Egypt. Finally he discusses how the Muslim scientist received the knowledge from contemporary civilizations of the time - Persian, Greek and Indian -and critically analyzed it, improved upon it by observation and research and applied it within the framework of the Islamic belief-system.

In this book, Prof. Haq Nadvi has indeed, admirably succeeded in putting the record straight as far as Islamic medicine is concerned. I sincerely hope and pray that it will inspire all of us to research our Muslim Medical heritage, learn from and emulate it, Insha-Allah.

Dr. Allie Moosa,
Professor, Faculty to Medicine,
University of Natal.
 

administrator

Islamic Medicine
Staff member
INTRODUCTION

Medicine is standing at its crossroads today. With ever increasing technological progress and scientific discoveries, the art of healing has been transformed to a highly specialized one, utilizing sophisticated machinery linked to that marvel of the electronic age, the computer. Decisions are now based on computer printouts of metabolic processes resulting in the doctor becoming part of the robotic process himself, becoming dehumanized to the extent that he comes to rely on miracle drugs and wonder machines and becoming oblivious of the Supreme Healer, the Creator and Sustainer of all life, Allah, the Beneficent and the Merciful.

In ever increasing numbers Muslim students from all over the world are imbibing medical knowledge at the fount of Western universities and Medical Schools, and then returning home to practice their respective arts, having sworn and dedicated themselves to uphold the glorified principles of the Hippocratic Oath, little realizing that the Oath is taken in the name of the mythical gods of Ancient Hellenism, and is sacrilegious to Islamic beliefs. They are not to be faulted for having lost sight of their great heritage, extending into all the disciplines of science, including the practice of medicine, for they are the products of academicians and universities geared to denigrate the contribution of Islam and the Quran to the entire human endeavour.

Muslim doctors in particular have been ignorant of the significant contribution rendered by the Quran and the Sunnah to the development of Medical sciences and very few are aware of the tomes of Arabic medical literature lying dormant in museums and libraries which contain ideas and knowledge on every conceivable field of medicine, from bacteriology, surgery, physiology, immunology, psychology, psychiatry and even to obstetrics and gynecology and ophthalmology, which are not only valid today, but in some cases far in advance of contemporary concepts held in the West.

Latest trends in medical thinking is the implication of diet in the causation of disease, a principle enshrined in the six principles of Prophetic Medicine fifteen centuries ago!

Concerning the Quranic imperatives, Imam Abi Abdullah Muhammad bin Ahmad az-Zahabi (643-748. C.E) with regard to food as a cause of disease, states that the Quran in Surah al-A'raf verse 31 has summarized the entire medicine in half an ayat:

0! Children of Adam, clothe yourselves decently at the Mosques, and eat and drink, but not in excess...' (VII: 31)

This is affirmed in the numerous Hadith which refer to the stomach as a tank (Hawd) of disease, and where it is enjoined that the stomach should be divided into thirds, each containing air, water and solids in equal proportions, and implying further that one should not eat to satiation! It is an undisputed fact that overeating or overindulgence results in various diseases, and imbalances between the diverse constituents of food in the nature of proteins, fats and carbohydrates also predisposes to diverse illnesses. In the less affluent, underrating (malnutrition), accounts for the death of three children every hour in the continent of Africa, whilst in an affluent country like South Africa, with plentiful supply of food, the mortality rate amongst us from heart attacks is the highest in the world More recently, an imbalance of fats in the diet has been implicated in the causation of cancer of the ovaries and breast in women. These facts lend support to the argument that most of disease is iatrogenic, i.e. caused by man himself, in not obeying the Quranic injunctions concerning food and healthy living.

This present work is, therefore, both salient and significant in that it draws- attention to the great contribution which Islamic Medicine has to offer to contemporary knowledge, and it points out the very vital and dynamic role played in medical history by the Arabs.

Their discoveries covered such fields as surgery, where the principles of suturing and wound treatment are still valid today, especially with reference to the treatment of war wounds. It is indeed ironical that Israel utilizes these principles on the battlefield in recent times whilst present day Muslim soldiers were denied these life-saving techniques!

Many of the Arab discoveries were surreptitiously copied by the Medieval philosophers, Roger Bacon's doctoral thesis on Optics is a classic example of plagiarism from the Arabs, whilst Ibn-Nafees' work on the pulmonary circulation was two centuries earlier than Harvey who is credited with it in the West. In the search of drugs, again arising from the Quranic description in Surah an-Naql (The Bee): "There issues from within their abdomens a drink of various hues wherein is healing for mankind..." (16:69). It was realized that different plants and flowers yield different varieties of honey. The search for these plants gave rise to the systematic study of botany and pharmacology. Muslims had discovered the use of alcohol as a drug and vehicle, and for anesthesia when they performed delicate operations of the eye, cystoscopy for the removal of kidney stones, and treatment for gonorrheal strictures which is still in use today. Vaccinations for smallpox was first introduced in Turkey and attributed in the West much later to Pasteur, and Muslims had an awareness of epidemics and their causes, as well as of bacteria long before Europe. They were the first to establish hospitals as we know them today, and for having separate wards for the different diseases. They also formed medical associations and had clinical meetings in which cases were discussed. Medical education as we know it today, with the idea of internships was initiated by Muslims as well as the standardization of drugs and price control.

This book ably proves that Muslims were never imitators as the West claims them to be, but innovators and initiators par excellence. The lesson to be derived from this is that contemporary students should be proud of their heritage and the work is a plea for more active participation by members of the medical profession who have been blessed with half of what constitutes knowledge according to the Sunna:

Knowledge is of two kinds, knowledge of the body and knowledge of Deen. It is possible to fulfill the latter half of this requirement by consolidated effort through the Islamic Medical Association, in order to render and practice holistic medicine, in the realization that Medical practice is not a vocation but an act of 'Ibadah with a responsibility one's Creator and His creation. Like any other act of 'Ibadah the art of Medicine, as a ritual, can and should be practiced in toto, paying full attention to all its requirements. This book is the first step to that performance.

Dr.G.M. Karim
 

administrator

Islamic Medicine
Staff member
PREFACE

Modern history records that not so long ago ambitious Europeans under the pretext of trading and exploration colonialised the Muslim lands all over the world. The youth, being the spinal column of the segment of Muslim society and being endowed with insight,

creativity, will power, concentration, memory, intuition, perseverance, mental vision, dynamic action and persuasion, were brainwashed by the colonialists through education. The colonial masters took a series of progressive steps towards misdirecting the inner potentials of Muslim youth. They hatched out an educational system to impress upon them that Islam had nothing original, but that everything was borrowed from Greek and other European cultures. This created a haunting inferiority complex and made them feel that the culture of the so-called superstratum was superior to the culture of the so-called substratum. The colonial powers patronized a class of writers known as Orientalists and conspired with them to produce massive anti-Islamic literature which would ingrain Muslim youth to regard Islamic Culture as inferior to that of the European and create in them a sense of guilt and shame for being Muslims, thus facilitating the entrenchment of their colonial masters in Muslim lands.

The foremost task of the Orientalists was to launch the most blustering and declamatory accusations against the Prophet of Islam - calling him an imposter, a liar, a magician, an epilectic and much more. The Muslim apologists joined them in the Anti-Hadith Movement. They destroyed the image of Islam as a creative culture and denied its contribution to any branch of human knowledge, including medicine. Libraries, homes, bookshops, bookdepots, universities, colleges and schools were flooded with this pernicious literature which paralyzed the creative thinking of Muslim youth. As a result they became sceptical about the truths of Islam. With the two world wars and the appalling dangers of the third global conflagration of unprecedented dimensions in the offing with the consequent impending destruction of the human race and culture indicate that man is badly in need of a God-fearing society and of pure literaturewhich makes him God-conscious. At the end of the Second World War in 1945, Muslim lands were emancipated from the colonial hands which allowed Muslim scholars and thinkers to reawaken from their deep slumber, exercise, their intellectual skill, challenge the so-called superstratum and thus Inspire the current resurgence of Islam through a series of Islamic literary productions.

Islamic Medical Associations, as guardians of the Islamic philosophy of medical knowledge in any part of the world, have manifold responsibilities towards the preservation and promotion of Islamic values and norms. Among many such obligations, only a few which can be enumerated here are:-

  • Stewardship of the Islamic medical ethics.
  • Islamic solution of day to day problems which have been created by the recent dramatic and meteoric rise of medical sciences.
  • Reconciliation between the religious ethics and the situation ethics and resolution of conflicting religious and secular values.
  • Revival of Arabic medical literature through studies of the contributions made by the early Islamic medical thinkers, philosophers and writers.
  • Convening of special seminars on the early Muslim medical writers and exploration of the areas of their specialization.
  • Introduction of early Muslim medical scholars and experts to contemporary Muslim youth who are ignorant of the original names of such scholars and they are oblivious of their works except their latinized names.
  • Purification of the intellectual and academic climate and the emancipation of Muslim youth from the prevailing inferiority complexes which have been created by the Orientalists.

Intellectual traditions and values are not merely inherited from our forebears. They are acquired, obtained and preserved by great sacrificing efforts of the inheritors of the traditions. The consciousness of the rich past can alone create a will to have a rich present and to aspire for a rich future. Traditions involve a historical sense and a historical sense involves a perception, not only of the pastiness of the past but also of its present and its future.

'Time Present and Time Past

Are both present in Time Future

And Time Future contained in Time Past '.


(TS. Eliot)
​

The great poet-philosopher Allama Muhammad Iqbal in his Persian verses renders the idea much more lucidly.

We expect and pray that this effort may stimulate and unfold the potential of our youth who intend pursuing studies in medical sciences. It is hoped that they will learn the Arabic language in order to understand the Qur'an and the Sunna, the primary sources of all Ulum (sciences) which developed under its inspiration. It is also expected that they will embark on researches on Ibn-Sina, Ibn-Rushd and ar-Rizi and others in the light of available data and research methodologies, seeking out new materials and thus render the unknown, the known.

This monograph was infact presented in an abridged form at the second annual conference of the Islamic Medical Association of South Africa (I.M.A.), held in Durban in May 1982, and then was enlarged for ail International Conference of Muslim Physicians. The purpose was to stimulate our young doctors for reflective study of the evolution of Islamic Medical Sciences as portrayed in Arabic and Persian medical literature, as well as to re-establish Truth, seeking historical justice in favour of the Muslim medical scientists of the past, not from the Orientalists but from our Muslim medical specialists. To remain silent or apologetic on the offensive views on Islam, a continuous challenge, is an intellectual and moral cowardice. It is hoped that this small monograph, without being comprehensive, will serve the purpose. My gratitudes are due to Dr. Allie Moosa, Professor of Pediatric medicine at the Natal Medical College, Durban, for writing the Foreword. Special thanks are due to Dr. G.M. Karim, the branch a chairman of I.M.A. in the Eastern Transvaal, who read the draft carefully, made valuable suggestions and wrote an inspiring Introduction. Mr. M.A. Khan merits mention for his technical assistance. This painful task was not possible without his diligence in proof-reading.

Syed Habibul Haq Nadvi
 

administrator

Islamic Medicine
Staff member
The Philosophy Of Medical Treatment In Islam

THE PHILOSOPHY OF MEDICAL TREATMENT IN ISLAM
​

Man has been created in the best of moulds (Ahsan-i-Taqwim). According to the Prophetic Tradition (Hadith) Allah has created man in His own image (Khalaqa-Allah

Adama 'Ala Suratihi). Thus, being the climax and the crown of the creation, man is an all-embracing theatre of Divine Hierophany and a source of ultimate effusion of Truth. Being the vicegerent of Allah (Khalifat-Allah) on earth and being a celestial archetype on earth lie has to bear and discharge the Divine Trust (Amana). An ideal creature like man cannot discharge his Amana without perfect and sound health-both physical and spiritual.

The concept of Original Sin and the treatment of man as a primary sinner, neither existed in Islam nor was disease ever regarded as the result of Original Sin, unworthy of any medical treatment. The rapid disintegration of his personality, according to Islam, is the result of his forgetfulness of the mission assigned to him as the representative of Allah on earth and because of his total identification with the world of passion and greed. He then loses the Divine Form and his theomorphic nature and he falls from the position of his vicegerency.

This was the philosophy which dominated the thinking of the Muslims through the centuries in every walk of life and in every field of knowledge, including Medicine. Eminent Muslim doctors and physicians, also being great scholars of the Qur'an and the Sunna, regarded medical service as a religious duty, incumbent upon them to sustain the health of the vicegerent of Allah in dynamic shape and function.
 

administrator

Islamic Medicine
Staff member
He Qur'anic Imperatives On Dietetics

THE QUR'ANIC IMPERATIVES ON DIETETICS
​

(Al-Ghadhaiyat) The first Divine injunctions in respect to human diet are found in the Qur'an. Since the health of the soul is linked to the health of the body and since both are interdependent and interrelated, the Creator of man,

Himself, cognizant of the biological needs of man, prescribed Halal and nourishing (Tayyab) food and prevented man from eating Haram and unhealthy food. Since diet is instrumental in preserving the health of man and since food controls the biological phenomena of the human body Muslim doctors and medical experts pondered over the Qur'anic verses and the jurists, exegetists, biographers and historians explained the verses in the light of the Prophetic Traditions (Ahadith dealing with Tibb-an-Nabawi-Prophetic Medicine), which gave rise to the primary Arabic medical literature. The doctors, physicians, surgeons and experts in other fields of medicine were inspired by the same religious injunctions and followed the dietary laws of the Qur'an in their medical treatment in order to save mankind from illness and physical infirmity. There is neither space nor occasion to deal with such verses in detail, yet a cursory glance over the verse dealing directly with dietetics will assist us in understanding the philosophy of medical treatment in Islam. The Qur'an addresses both the believers and the non-believers in regard to their diet. Addressing humans in general the Qur'an commands:

0, ye people! eat of what is on earth, lawful and good and do not follow the footsteps of the evil one, for he is to you an avowed enemy (11:168).

The believers have also been addressed in a similar tone:

0, ye who believe, eat of the good things that We have provided for you and be grateful to God, if it is Him ye worship (11:172)

From the Qur'anic verses it is evident that lawful (Halal) food is regarded as a prerequisite for the maintenance of sound health whilst the forbidden and unlawful (Haram) food has been described as injurious and impious to health, causing illness and physical ailments. The recurring theme of Halal food leads us to believe that prevention is better than cure. Haram food leads man to offensive and sinful deeds while Halal food leads him to licit deeds. The following verses merit our attention:

Eat of the good things what We have provided for you. (But they rebelled). To Us they did no harm, but they harmed their own souls (11:57).


So eat and drink of the sustenance provided by God, and do not evil nor mischief on the (face of the) earth (11:60).


0, ye who believe! Make not unlawful, the good things which God hath made lawful for you. But commit no excess for God loveth not those given to excess. Eat of the things, which God hath provided for you, lawful and good (Halal and Tayyab); but fear God in whom ye believe (V: 90-91).


Eat what God hath provided for you, and follow not the footsteps of Satan, for he is to you an avowed enemy (VI: 142).

Eat the good things We have provided for you, (But they rebelled). They did no harm, but they harmed their own souls (VII: 160).

But (now) enjoy what ye took in war, lawful and good: But fear God for God is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful (VIII: 69).

So eat of the sustenance which God hath provided for you, lawful and good (Halal and Tayyab). And be grateful for the favours of God, if it is He whom ye serve (XVI: 114).
​

Eat of the good things We have provided for your sustenance, but commit no excess therein, lest My Wrath should justly descend on you: and those on whom descends My Wrath do perish indeed! (XX: 81).

In addition to its emphasis on Halal and Tayyab food, the Qur'an also lays stress on eating the meat of such animals which have been slaughtered in the name of Allah. Consuming of non-Halal meat has been described as sinful (Fisq) which leads to moral depravity and dissolute life:

  1. So eat of (meats) on which God's name hath been pronounced, if ye have faith in His Sings. Why should ye not eat of (meats) on which God's name hath been pronounced, when He hath explained to you in detail what is forbidden to you except under compulsion of necessity? But many do mislead (men) by their appetites unchecked by knowledge. Thy lord knoweth best those who transgress (VI: 118-119).
  2. Eat not of (meats) on which God's name hath not been pronounced: that would be impiety (Fisq). But the evil ones ever inspire their friends to contend with you. If ye were to obey them, ye would indeed be Pagans. (VI: 121).

The overindulgence and wastage of food have been condemned by Allah in the following words:

O children of Adam! Wear your beautiful apparel at every time and place of prayer: eat and drink: But waste not by excess, for God loveth not the wasters. (VII: 31)
​

The Qur'anic verse clearly indicates that good and Halal (lawful) diet stimulates man for virtuous and pious deeds (A'mal-i-Saleh) and creates Godly character. Addressing His own Messengers, Allah guides them in the following words:

O ye Apostles! Enjoy and eat all things good and pure, and work righteousness: for I am well acquainted with (all) that ye do. (XXIII: 51).

Eat and drink ye, with profit and health, because of your good deeds. (LII: 19).
​

Although the later verses are symbolical descriptions of life in heaven, they are down to earth. The bliss of righteousness is the result of the bliss of Halal and good sustenance, which provides individual bliss as well as the social bliss together with individual satisfaction that one obtains through sound health and pious works. It is only those who do good works, which are products of good and pure diet, shall have the throne of dignity. The words 'eating' and 'drinking', if taken in the non-literal sense, generate enormous meanings. They also imply that one should neither eat up the money of the orphans, widows or the weak, nor should one earn his livelihood through Haram means, that is, injustice, theft, forgery, exploitation etc. There is no bliss (Baraka) in life today since seldom do we eat the earnings of Halal money or Halal sources.

The Arabic imperatives (Kulu: eat) have been used throughout the Qur'an. They are very significant since the jurists interpret the imperatives as a collective duty (Fard al-Kifaya). Excessive eating or wastage (Israf) has been forbidden by the Qur'an. Contemporary medical science has been very much concerned with regulating food intake (dieting) and using normal healthy food for the nourishment and preservation of health.

In Islam the sanctity of human life can beevaluated in many verses in the Qur'an, which allow man to eat non-Halal food in emergencies, namely, if his life is in danger or medical necessities demand administering such food to the patient in order to save his life. The Qur'an first lists Haram foods and then relaxes the dietary laws only to save human life - a sacred trust (Amana) from God given to man.

He hath forbidden you dead meat, and blood, and the flesh of swine, and that on which any other name hath been invoked besides that of God. But if one is forced by necessity, without willful disobedience, nor transgressing due limits, then he is guiltless. For God is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful'. (II: 173).

Thus the Holy Qur'an spells out the infallible Divine Wisdom and Infinite Mercies of the Creator to man who is but endowed with limited and fallible wisdom and finite vision.
 
Top